Cookies, Cupcakes, and Cardio

Step by step homemade baking recipes

  • Home
  • Baking Bucket List
  • Recipes
    • Converting to Metric
  • About Me
    • What I Love to Love
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
  • Cookbook
  • Cakes
  • Cardio
    • Weights
    • Running
    • Spinning
    • Hiking
  • Cookies
  • Cupcakes
  • Tutorials
    • Videos
  • Other Baked Goodies
    • Holiday Baking
  • Randomness
    • What I’m Reading
    • The Beginning
    • Fortunate Fridays

Frosting Filled Birthday Cake Cookies- Chips Ahoy Copycat Recipe

August 27, 2014 by Jenn

I am obsessed with anything that is cake flavoured- birthday cake, cake batter- anything!  I especially love the ones with the sprinkles!!!  So obviously when I saw Frosting Filled Birthday Cake Cookies from Chips Ahoy on the shelf at the grocery store, I snatched them up before anyone else could steal them away from me.  

I don’t think I’ve been more excited to try something than I was to try these cookies- I’ve never seen frosting filled in a cookie before-  I took one bite, and was devastated!  They were not very good.  At all.  They didn’t taste like cake batter, and they sure didn’t taste like frosting!  Being the devoted sweets fan that I am, I new I couldn’t give up at that point, and I had to try to make my own version.  

To make the frosting filling, I ended up using shortening, which I don’t usually like to use.  I tried the recipe with butter instead, but the butter melted in the heat of the oven, and the frosting spread out all over the cookies.  I also failed when it came to the cookie batter.  I went with my go-to chocolate chip cookie batter, and found that it didn’t have enough flour, so the cookies spread out wide.  I needed them to keep their bowl shape around the frosting filling.  So, I fixed my errors, replaced the butter with the shortening, and added more flour.  One more practice batch, and I had it fixed!  

 I hope you love these as much as I did!

[Read more…]

PinterestShare
Filed Under: Cookies, Tutorials, Videos Tagged With: birthday cake cookies, birthday cookies, chocolate chip birthday cookies, chocolate chip cookies, cookies, frosting filled birthday cookies, frosting filled chocolate chip cookies, frosting filled cookies, frosting stuffed cookies, stuffed cookies

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Stuffed Triple Peanut Butter Cookies

July 23, 2014 by Jenn

 

If you are a peanut butter lover, you need to add this to your list of MUST make recipes. 

Are you ready?  These cookies have peanut butter, peanut butter chips, Reese’s Pieces, and all of that deliciousness is wrapped around a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup!

Obviously, if you are NOT a peanut butter fan (what is wrong with you?) these are not the cookies for you.  I apologize to you for having to lose out on the amazingness of these cookies.  If you’re allergic, how to do you live life?!?!?  I really feel for you.  Seriously.  No sarcasm.  THAT’s how bad I feel- bad enough to not be sarcastic!  I would guess that you could substitute the peanut butter portions for a nut free alternatives, but I haven’t checked that out yet. 

This is a pretty straightforward cookie recipe, so following the steps to combine the ingredients is relatively easy.  When baking these cookies, you want to make sure that you wrap the dough entirely around the peanut butter cup.  This will prevent any of the peanut butter cup/chocolate from escaping during baking.  I didn’t have that problem, but if you do freezing the peanut butter cups ahead of time might help as well. 

[Read more…]

PinterestShare
Filed Under: Cookies, Videos Tagged With: cookies, peanut butter, peanut butter chips, peanut butter cookies, reece's peanut butter cups, reece's peanut butter cups stuffed cookies, reece's pieces, stuffed, stuffed cookies, triple peanut butter

Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookie

April 2, 2011 by Jenn

Yes, you read that right.  A huge chocolate chip cookie, stuffed with an Oreo cookie inside (double stuffed Oreo, I might add!)

Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookie

This recipe has been ripping around the blogosphere, and I had to jump on the bandwagon.  How could I not?!  Combining two of the baking world’s greatest things into one huge treat is a MUST do!

I have to say, this particular chocolate chip cookie recipe has just the right amount of salt in it. This “sandwich” (aka glutinous delight) has that perfect sweet and salty aura to it.  If you are a sweet and salty lover like myself, you will LOVE this recipe.

I wanted to make something unique for my Cakery’s table at the local Farmers Market for last weekend.  A new cupcake table had been set up (in MY spot I have to add), so I wanted to have something unique to sell.  My cupcakes have the glam factor to them that makes them the best cupcakes around, but sometimes, you need something novel to bring the people in!

These cookies definitely did the trick.  I had one sliced in half, so people could see them from the aisle, and I can’t tell you how many times I heard “Is that a-?  Oh!  It IS an Oreo!” We sold out of these babies.

The original recipe for this delight comes from the Picky Palate, and if you haven’t been there before, go there now.  NO, WAIT!  Go when you’re done reading (and commenting) here first!

Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies

(from Picky Palate)

As usual, start by creaming together butter and sugars . . . ode to the Kitchen Aid.  Let’s take a moment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .  oh, how I love thee.

Next, mix in the eggs.

And the vanilla.

Then the dry stuff . . . yes, that is my near empty container of flour.  Man does this job use a lot of flour and sugar!  I’m forever buying it . . . and there is a thin layering of white sugar/flour dust on every single instrument in the kitchen!

Add in the chocolate chips.

Using a cookie scoop, arrange one ball, per cookie.

Next, place an Oreo on top of the original cookie dough ball, and then place another on top of the Oreo.

Gently squeeze the dough together and attach around the whole Oreo.  It’s actually simpler than it sounds.

They should look something like these gigantic balls of delicious cookie dough!

Fresh from the oven . . . I’ve put in an Oreo to show you the size of the baked “sandwich”.

YUM!  So good.  I tried so save this sample version for the market the next day, but I couldn’t resist, and had to eat a half.  I left half for Paul (seriously, I managed to resist it’s calls to me all day). I figure it’s all in the name of product research . . . I can’t sell something that I haven’t tried, right?

Here’s the link to the recipe.  Thanks Picky Palate for “inventing” such a delightful treat.

PinterestShare
Filed Under: Cookies Tagged With: chocolate chip cookies, cookies, Oreo, stuffed cookies

Happiness is Homemade

Join Me On:






Subscribe

Tags

baking birthday birthday cake birthday cakes buttercream cake cake decorating cake design cake pops cake recipe cake recipes cakes cakes cranbrook candy candy cake chocolate chocolate cake Christmas cookies Cookies Cupcakes and Cardio Cranbrook cranbrook cakes cupcake cupcakes Cupcakes and Cardio dessert easter fondant Halloween homemade how-to how to make how to make cake Icing jenn johns jj's custom cakery No Bake peanut butter rainbow Rainbow cake recipe surprise inside surprise inside cake valentine's day wedding cake

Site Stuff

  • RSS Feed Sign-Up
  • Privacy Policy

Return to top of page

Cookies, Cupcakes, and Cardio© 2025 • Design by Simply Chic Blog Boutique